-
Who this checklist is for
-
The checklist
-
1. Walk the building and count what's actually mounted
-
2. Check refill compatibility before you look at price
-
3. Get the spec sheet, not the brochure
-
4. Pilot one unit in the worst restroom you have
-
5. Confirm invoicing and PO process before you place the order
-
6. Calculate cost per use, not cost per case
-
7. Ask who services a jammed dispenser
-
8. Write down your reorder threshold and stick to it
-
1. Walk the building and count what's actually mounted
- Where people go wrong
Who this checklist is for
I'm the office administrator for a 300-person company. I handle all facilities and office supply ordering — roughly $170,000 a year across nine vendors — and I report to both operations and finance. Paper towel dispensers are maybe 3% of that budget and about 40% of my headaches.
This list is for anyone about to place a dispenser order, switch suppliers, or replace units across a building. Eight steps. About 90 minutes the first time you run it, closer to 20 minutes after that. It's the list I wish someone had handed me back in 2020, when I was still doing this off a spreadsheet someone else had abandoned.
The checklist
1. Walk the building and count what's actually mounted
Not what's on last year's purchase order. Not what the vendor's rep thinks is there. What's physically screwed into the wall.
The first time I did this I counted 37 dispensers. Our incumbent quote was based on 24. Nobody had updated the count since a 2019 renovation, and two of the "missing" units had been quietly swapped for a different model by a maintenance contractor during a lighting project. That mismatch alone was worth about $600 a year in over-ordering.
Take photos. Note model numbers. You'll need them for step 3.
2. Check refill compatibility before you look at price
Most buyers focus on the case price and completely miss the refill lock-in. A dispenser that only accepts one proprietary refill isn't a purchase — it's a subscription, and the per-case price stops mattering the moment you're locked in.
Ask two questions: does this model take universal refills, and what happens to the per-case price at renewal? Get both answers in writing, not on a call.
3. Get the spec sheet, not the brochure
Brochures show a smiling person pulling a perfect sheet of towel. Spec sheets show capacity, roll dimensions, compatible refill codes, and where the unit was manufactured. That's the document you actually need.
If you've ever searched "Kimberly-Clark Chester Mill" late at night trying to work out which facility your order ships from, you already know why this matters. The answer isn't in the sales email. The Kimberly-Clark Professional spec sheets I pulled in January listed the compatible refill codes right on the page — that's the standard to hold every quote to. Check that the part numbers on the quote match the ones on the sheet.
4. Pilot one unit in the worst restroom you have
Pick the restroom with the heaviest traffic and the grumpiest users. Install one dispenser. Leave it two weeks. Don't tell anyone you're testing anything.
I skipped this step once and bought 18 units off a showroom demo. They worked great in the showroom (surprise, surprise). In a real restroom, with real humidity and real people yanking, the sheets tore at roughly a 30% rate and we ended up double-feeding on nearly every pull. That's not a spec failure. That's a pilot failure.
5. Confirm invoicing and PO process before you place the order
This is the boring one, and it's the one that gets your expense report bounced back to you in red ink.
In 2021, I found a great price from a new vendor — about 18% cheaper than our regular supplier. I ordered four pallets. They couldn't provide a proper invoice (handwritten receipt only). Finance rejected the expense report. I ate $2,400 out of the department budget. Now I verify invoicing capability before placing any order.
Ask for three things up front:
- A sample invoice, with your PO number on it
- A W-9
- Written confirmation they can accept your PO format
If they hesitate on any of those, walk. There are plenty of vendors who can do all three without blinking. And yes — even after switching to a vendor who checked every box, I second-guessed myself for a month. What if the quality slipped after the first order? The two deliveries were fine. That's when I finally relaxed.
6. Calculate cost per use, not cost per case
A case of cheap towels that people pull three at a time is more expensive than a case of good ones people pull once. I built a deeply unglamorous spreadsheet that tracks sheets per case, sheets per use, and uses per dispenser per day. The "cheaper" brand came out about 11% more expensive per use once the double-pulling was factored in.
You don't need a complicated model. You need three numbers and two weeks of observation. When we were weighing the switch, the upside was roughly $3,000 a year and the risk was a full re-stock if the refills didn't seat properly. I kept asking myself: is $3,000 worth potentially eating $3,000 in unusable product? The pilot in step 4 is how you stop guessing.
7. Ask who services a jammed dispenser
Dispensers jam. Rollers wear out. Someone will knock one off a ladder during a lighting swap. The question is whether you're calling your vendor, your janitorial contractor, or a maintenance tech — and who pays for the call-out.
Get that in writing too. I've been quoted a "full service" package that turned out to mean "we'll open a ticket and get back to you in 3–5 business days." For a restroom with 200 daily users, that's not service. That's a queue.
8. Write down your reorder threshold and stick to it
Not in your head. In the shared drive, with your name and a date on it, so the next person doesn't have to rebuild the whole thing from scratch.
Ours is two cases per model, flagged at four. That's it. We standardized on Kimberly-Clark paper towel dispensers across three sites in 2023 and the count hasn't drifted since, mostly because it's documented. This checklist has saved us somewhere around $8,000 in avoided rework and rush orders over three years. Five minutes of verification beats five days of correction.
Where people go wrong
Conflating consumer towels with commercial ones
I get asked about this a lot, usually by someone who's been comparison shopping on their lunch break. A Sonoma ultimate bath towel or a clearance bath towel from a department store is a completely different product from a commercial hand towel — different ply, different absorbency, different lint behavior, and none of it is rated for the duty cycle of a restroom with 200 users a day. Buying consumer towels in bulk to "save money" looks fine until week three, and then it looks like a maintenance ticket.
The hygiene question
Every few months somebody asks me some version of "is it ok to use the same towel for a week" — usually about bath towels at home, sometimes about shop towels on the warehouse floor. At home, that's your call and I'm not going to play doctor. In a facility, it's a different question altogether. It's not really about how long a towel lasts. It's about whether the dispenser design and the refill cycle actually match the traffic in that room. Different problem, different answer. Don't let one conversation bleed into the other when you're writing a spec.
The sample-size problem
One caveat, and it's a real one: my experience is based on about four rounds of dispenser procurement across three office buildings. If you're outfitting a hospital, a food production floor, or anything with regulatory hygiene requirements, your specs will be tighter than mine and this list won't cover everything. Talk to someone who does that for a living.
If you take one thing away: verify before you sign. The expensive mistakes in procurement almost never happen at the moment of purchase. They happen two weeks earlier, when nobody checked the refill code or the invoice format. Do the boring work up front. It's cheaper.

